They’re often a fact of life to be borne like the trials of Job, but not always. Control interviewed three different end users of Siemens’ new Sitrans LR-series radar-level transmitters. Facility applications ranged from recycling to steel to plastics, which all reported little trouble with the Siemens units.
Safety Kleen Holdco’s plant in Denton, Texas, processes clients’ discarded chemicals into fuel for cement kilns. These processes require precise level measurement in difficult environments. Bill Bakus, Safety Kleen’s plant engineer, reports his facility has been using seven Sitrans LR200 radar level transmitters for about two years, with only one unexplained failure. He says the units are easy to install and calibrate. Getting the power in conduit to the outside tanks was the biggest part of the installation, with physical mounting of the Sitrans units taking just minutes.
Since then, the units have been nearly maintenance-free, in contrast to the hour or so required monthly for the floating tape-measure units they replaced. These former units were in place 25 to 30 years, and weren’t ideal for the plant’s mixes of slurries and sludges—with 35%-40% solids—in the tanks. Bakus adds that long-term they’ll likely set things up to centralize access to Sitrans units’ data via Ethernet.
Likewise, almost any electronic application in a steel mill is challenging, and this is the case with 28 silos at the Nucor mill in Decatur, Ala. They contain manufactured or smelted materials for alloying end products. One example, with a special challenge on the dust side, is carbon—at 8µ-10 µ (by comparison cigarette smoke is ~40 µ)—where Siemens’ units can “see” the material interface.
Andrew Smith, Nucor electrical engineer, reports that since Nucor purchased the plant. it has tripled output, and that plant automation is a key aid. Siemens’ LR400s reduced maintenance and have been failure-free. By contrast, their predecessors experienced:
- Dust that destroyed bearings and penetrated enclosures, yielding only six-month lives for the four former units;
- Variable material densities, hardnesses and angles of repose that presented difficulties for other units;
- Multiple false reflections and minerals in the silos that abraded wire ropes used for suspension.
Smith says LR400 is easy to aim, can be kept out of the fill stream and accounts for the measured materials’ angle of repose. With plant device manager (PDM) software, a profile can be set up for each silo’s material. He adds that, while the units are connected to the plant’s HART network, maintenance and supervisory personnel can easily monitor the 34 units on their rounds, using handheld infrared monitors.
Smith said Nucor did have some problems with Sitrans. Dust got into the waveguide, but this was solved with pipe tape. Also, with temperatures up to 160 °F-200 °F, there are some freeze-ups or high or low readings.
Preventive maintenance (PM) is conducted every 90 days. Since only four bolts hold down the units, this only takes 15 minutes per unit. PM on prior units could be done only on “down days” and needed man-lifts to access the silos’ sides.
Nucor is putting in another tank farm with 14 more silos for fluxes that will be equipped with Sitrans LR460s. Smith’s only concern is controlling dust build-up. Dust cap integrity is essential. If dust cakes inside the “horn,” transmitted and returns signals are distorted.
Smith says he “likes Sitrans units’ reliability, maintainability and consistency of measurement.” He also was impressed with Siemens’ rapid tech support that can troubleshoot issues via phone or Internet connection.
Likewise, DuPont’s SRW plastics and synthetic resins plant in Orange, Texas, is in a tough, 300 °F environment. Veryl Williams, electrical and instrument engineer, says levels in both the feed (prill and pellet wax) and melt tanks are important. Prior level measurement was capacitance-based with a float and dip-tube arrangement that had to be cleaned every six or seven months—when the process was down.
So when Williams was looking for a non-intrusive method, LR 250’s beta version fit the bill. He noted that with the mounting flange 6 in. off the tank wall, Siemens’ software factored out the nuisance reflections.
The two LR250s have been in service trouble-free at DuPont for two years now. In the future, Williams says these units will be integrated into the plant’s automation monitoring system.