Home » Which Way for the Wireless Waves?
Which Way for the Wireless Waves?
By Nick Denbow, Industrial Automation Insider
The progress to standardization of wireless systems continues, as you might expect, to march down the several different directions that each supplier feels suits its business model best. The ISA100.12 committee, revitalized by a user revolt last year, met alongside the ARC Forum in Orlando to review three proposals as to how to establish a future working relationship between the polarized opinions.
A report of this meeting by Walt Boyes on his ControlGlobal SoundOff! blog suggests that the first group, the "Heathrow Group" of WirelessHART enthusiasts—ABB, Emerson, Endress + Hauser and Siemens—suggests the IEC62591 could be upgraded to include the useful aspects of ISA100.11a and the Chinese WIA-PA standard.
The second group, the ISA100.11a enthusiasts—Honeywell, Invensys, Nivis, Yokogawa, Fuji, Hitachi and Yamatake—say we only want an ISA100 approach because it covers everything (that we suppliers want to see in there).
The third group is GE, standing alone, suggesting rewriting ISA100.11a to be an umbrella standard under which IEC62591, ISA100.11a as it exists at present and WIA-PA are capable of being used in the same network framework with the same backhaul.
So What's New?
The INSIDER in July 2010 applauded the Nivis announcement that it could offer a dual WirelessHART/ISA100.11a gateway, which enables the essence of the proposal made by GE. The impression from discussions with Rockwell and Honeywell has been that their plant automation systems will be made capable of dealing with whatever wireless standards are appropriate or in use on their customer’s plant. After all that is their business capability, or even a requirement for their business.
The inclusion of Invensys in the ISA100.11a group seemed surprising, given its broad tolerance to working with any system, as also expressed in response to questions at OpsManage last year. Indeed, its whole approach to the InFusion Enterprise Control System also requires the capability to work with communications via all available interfaces and systems, so does this apparently new alignment alongside the ISA100.11a protagonists signal any change of view?
The response from Hesh Kagan, whose current job title at Invensys is "Portfolio Architect, Technology Innovations," provided via Stephen Ballard of the Invensys UK PR agency was that "Invensys has been supporting the development of ISA100 as an open standard since the beginning. We believe the ISA100 architecture is consistent with our view of enterprise wide industrial wireless and the overall ECS concept. The development of ISA100 was accomplished with the participation of many WirelessHART proponents and includes all of the functionality of HART plus many other functional capabilities required to meet the current and future application requirements of our users."
Interestingly Kagan was reported in the INSIDER of October 09 as saying that "I do believe in meeting your customer's needs" and predicted the rapid emergence of a multitude of gateways and other devices to enable networks based on the two standards to coexist within the same environment. That said, his own preference was clearly for ISA 100.11 which, he said, in contrast to WirelessHART, provides "a lot of headroom" for the development of a much wider range of potential applications.
Looking back still further, to the INSIDER three years ago (August 08), shows a little more of Kagan's insight, when he said: "My belief is that this technology becomes compelling at the point where it reaches the top of the 'S' curve in three to five years time. At that point activity becomes frenetic."
For 2011, Kagan adds a different viewpoint on the Orlando discussions last month. "We (Invensys) are additionally participating on the 'Heathrow' team to try to reconcile differences between the ISA and WirelessHART standards to achieve one standard. We presented (with Honeywell and Yokogawa) a joint proposal to add a HART communications object to the ISA100 protocol at the recent ISA100.11a meeting in Orlando. We think that this creates the best overall solution for convergence and a unified wireless architecture."
ProComSol Distributes PowerXpress HART Power Solution
ProComSol Announces It Now Distributes PowerXpress HART Calibration Power Solution
West Texas Investigation Hampered by Inter-Agency Cat Fight
ATF and CSB in dispute about access to plant, witnesses, evidence.
News You Might Have Missed This Week from ControlGlobal and Elsewhere
Our Recap of Stories, Events and Ideas Floating Around the Internet Now
Fieldbus Foundation Launches Project Gemstone
New initiative is designed to make the fieldbus experience easier, more application-centered.
Pressure Sensors Monitor Remote Field Safety Trailers
AST Pressure sensors are used to monitor Nomadic safety trailers in the field in remote oil field locations.
Great Moments in Process Automation History
Take a broken soda fountain machine, a car a.c. unit, flavor mixes, water and CO2, add inventiveness; you get America’s favorite frozen drink.
Smart Grid: Independent Testing Of Rossi's E-Cat Cold Fusion Device Shows Positive Results
Forbes magazine's tech contributor Mark Gibbs writes that independent testing of Andrea Rossi's E-CAT Cold Fusion Reactor has positive results.The implications of the possible commercialization of cold fusion power sources are incredible.
Compressor Controls: Saudi Aramco Buys First GE Compressor Control Systems
Saudi Aramco has purchased advanced compressor control technology from GE for the Haradh GOSP-1 facility in Saudi Arabia's Eastern Province.
SANS Control Security Training Coming to Houston
SANS Institute will hold ICS Security Training event on June 10-15 in Houston
ISA Training Through June in Houston
Technician training, engineering survival and SIS boot camps for condensed, intense, comprehensive educational experience.
- All news »
Access the entire print issue on-line and be notified each month via e-mail when your new issue is ready for you. Subscribe today.
- Featured White Papers