Voices: Boyes

Happy New Year...We Hope!

If We Won't Steer Our Own Kids Towards STEM Careers, How Can We Justify Pushing Other Kids into Manufacturing?

By Walt Boyes, Editor in Chief

According to all the pundits, we should be recovering from the worst economic disaster since the Great Depression. We can all fervently hope so. Revenues have been going up for automation companies, which means that asset owners and end users have been loosening the purse strings. Hiring of automation professionals is increasing worldwide and because there is a worldwide shortage of qualified professionals, wages and benefits appear to be going up in most places.

That's good.

What's not good is that we continue to kill ourselves with monotonous regularity. Last year, the ASM Consortium (www.asmconsortium.com) tracked process industry accidents and concluded that there were well over 100 of them, with more than 25 fatalities. The root cause of most of those accidents was the same: failure to follow proper safety procedures.

What's also not so good is the increasing reliance of both end users and automation companies on new employees, who are being asked to do more, but with much less training or experience than we have. This is a time bomb.

We can't rely on the existing types of control systems in plants if we don't have highly experienced operators and engineers who can run them. The board operator on the Deepwater Horizon had been trained what to do for every alarm she might face—but never trained on which alarms to concentrate on in the event of a total alarm cascade. So when it happened, she was paralyzed and didn't know what to do.

A few years ago, I proposed that the automation vendors get together and fund the development and distribution of an online role-playing game that I called "Process Hero." Such a game would help to do two things we desperately need. First, it would get young people to consider careers in process automation as they learn how to operate and manage a process plant. Second, it would give a whole new generation of potential operators that situational awareness commanded by the 30+ year operators who've been retiring in droves. I still think it's a good idea, and maybe somebody out there will turn up with enough cash to do the project. The technology is certainly available for the virtual plant.

The current situation—not enough young people entering the business—is one we can all help address. Encourage your children to follow you into a science, engineering, technology or mathematics career. If we won't do it for our own kids, how can we justify pushing other kids into manufacturing? Manufacturing is going to get very smart, and become even more high tech than it already is. It will be a fulfilling job and pay very well, with more stability than manufacturing jobs have had in a long time.

If we keep discouraging our kids from going into STEM curricula in high school and college and then working in manufacturing, all the young engineers and operators in China and India will need to be recruited for our manufacturing plants—and they will get all the high paying jobs because, in China and India working in manufacturing is a high-status profession.

It isn't up to the asset owners, or the vendor community or the government either. It is up to each and every one of us to see to it that manufacturing is alive and well in North America and Western Europe, just as it will be in South America, Eastern Europe and Asia by the time we retire. And those of you younger than the average age of automation professionals (about 45) will need to replace yourselves too.

Encourage your children, your relatives' children and even kids you meet on the street, for heaven's sake, to become engineers, scientists and technicians. That's a New Year's resolution we can all make and be proud of.

More from this voice


The Big Technological Content Mountain

We're in the Process of Curating the Best Content on the Web for You


Wireless May Make Valve Maintenance Easier

Should You Use Wireless in Managing Your Valve Assets?


How can we save ISA?

The resignation of ISA’s third Executive Director in less than six years makes CONTROL Editor in Chief Walt Boyes wonder what ISA has that still matters to the typical process automation end user.


In the future: More, better, cheaper sensors

According to Editor in Chief Walt Boyes, instrumentation companies are going to have to re-think their design criteria if they are going to make the “lights out” plant of the future practical.


What’s in a Name?

ISA Council of Society Delegates votes to rename the society the International Society for Automation.


A Quick Pause for Shameless Self-Congratulation

Walt Boyes Says: "We're Still Here, and We’ve Created the Best Magazine in the Space"


The Horse with Stripes

IT Security Professionals Profess to Be “Industrial Cyber Security ," Yet, It Takes More to Function Properly in the Industrial Controls Environment


Just Because They Haven’t, Doesn’t Mean They Won’t

At the SANS Conference in January, CIA Representative Tom Donahue Revealed that the Agency Had Documentary Evidence of Attacks on Utilities Outside the U.S. Of Course, If Systems Can Be Hacked Outside the U.S., the Same Systems Are Vulnerable Inside. And the Systems Are the Same.


Get 'em While They're Young

We need to attract new star talent to the automation profession.


What’s It Going to Take?

The ASM Consortium, and the Center for Chemical Process Safety, ISA, the IEC and other organizations have been out beating the drum for increased operator training and improved alarm management and human-machine-interfaces.


Finally playing nice

Editor in Chief Walt Boyes congratulates the members of the SP100 Industrial Wireless Standard committee for their willingness to compromise in the name of service to the end-user community.


Take one for the team!

Organizations that only serve declining memberships are missing the point. The number of automation professionals isn’t declining; it is the number of them who feel the need to be included that’s declining.


Out of the Automation Box

ISA announces the S100 Compliance Institute to test and enforce compliance with new wireless standard. The S100 will be avilable to the publin in late 2008.


Sometimes You Just Have to Let Go

ISA Has Decided to Use the Compliance Institutes as a Way to Recover the Lost Revenue from the Dying ISA Show


The Elephant in the Room

There’s an Elephant in the Wireless Room


It Looks Like Up to Me…

The Process Industries Will Be Among the Least Affected of the Industrial Verticals by the Global Economic Meltdown


What Is To Be Done?

Who’s Going to Step Up and Create A Global Infrastructure Computer Emergency Response Team?


Shrink-Proof Your Career

Read This Article and Find Out Why Boyes Says That Automation Professionals Have Been Less Hurt by the Recession Than Other Professionals


ISA100.11a: Half Baked to a Schedule

If this Standard's Not Done, It Shouldn't Be Leaving the Oven


If They Can, Why Haven’t They?

It’s the Time Between When the Vulnerability Is Found and When It Is Fixed by the Vendor and the Fix Is Installed by the End User That Is Scary