Voices: Feedback

Reader Feedback: Who Do You Trust? People or Machines?

If We Trust the Machine, Are We Not Trusting Another Human to Correctly Program the Machine to Always Take Corrective Action?

By J. Troy Martel

In the "Ask the Experts" department in  Control's August 2014 issue, "The Proper Role of Automation?"/articles/2014/what-is-the-proper-role-of-automation/ (p. 54), Béla Lipták references the 1979 TMI and the 2009 Air France 447 accidents to propose adding additional critical control and safety systems, or modifying current systems to prevent operator action that overrides the safety function (OSC).

Read more

More from this voice

Title

Hoist by our own petard

Reader Feedback from the February issue says that when the game leaves town, people are left twiddling their thumbs, and that the passivity of engineers is the true enemy, not the Chinese.

02/15/2005

Your Skills; Security Requirements for Vendors

Getting the Message Across. WIB's Security Requirements for Vendors is a Good Start

01/10/2011

Where to Go for Training

Process Automation Engineers Look for Online Training. Do You Know of Any Programs?

02/10/2011

Control Readers Speak Up

International Readers Lets Us Know About Automation Training Opportunities Abroad and One of Our Readers Challenges Our Contributing Editor, Bela Liptak

03/08/2011

Fieldbus Errors; Tweet This, Not That

Factual Errors Connected With Profibus and Foundation Fieldbus and What the Tweet!!?

04/04/2011

Reader Feedback: Process Automation, Control Valves vs. VFDs and More

Readers Agree, Disagree and Respond to Some of Our Latest Articles. See What They Have to Say

05/02/2011

Automation Apps, Gaming Systems and Thermodynamic Steam Quality

Readers Ask for Clarification on Some of Our Latest Articles

06/07/2011

Readers Respond to Cybersecurity and Temperature Measurement Compensation

Readers Agree With Our Cybersecurity Coverage and Ask Why the Methods of Compensation Were Not Addressed by Our Industry Experts

07/05/2011

Summer and Stuxnet

Talking Plant Cybersecurity in the Light of Stuxnet. With No Certifications for Control System Cybersecurity, Anyone Can Be an Expert. Who Does an End User Believe?

08/02/2011

A Cybersecurity Wiki?

There Should Certainly Be a Wikipedia-Like Site for Security Professionals to Turn To for Proven, Tested Remedies and Suggestions

09/01/2011

Basics of Analyzer Systems Busted!

You're Right. Here's the Correct Wording

11/03/2011

Nice Article

Reader's Agree With Cybersecurity Article

11/03/2011

Answer to Our Question of the Month

Would You Pay for Outside Help to Address Cybersecurity Issues?

11/03/2011

More About VFDs

Why Flow Control With a VSD on a Pump Is for the Most Part Linear

01/05/2012

Safety First?

The Wind Power Industry Is Experiencing a Learning Curve in Safety and Accident Prevention

01/05/2012

Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire?

Our Very Own Ask the Experts Moderator Bela Liptak Learns a Lesson From One of Our Readers. Liptak Admits That Even Knowledgable People Can Be Wrong

02/06/2012

Really? A Political Diatribe?

Reader Disagrees with Editor in Chief Walt Boyes's View on External Cyber Attacks Dangers and U.S. Cybersecurity Policies

02/06/2012

An Update on Liptak and Shinskey

Greg Shinskey Continues to Do Consulting and Bela Liptak Talks on Optimization and Safety

02/06/2012

Is STEM Education Gone for Good?

Employers Today Abuse the H1-B Visa Program and Want to Pay Next to Nothing for a "Rocket Scientist"

03/05/2012

The Future of Manufacturing?

Here Is A Reader's Point of View on What Manufacturing in America Actually Would Look Like

03/05/2012