Voices: Feedback

Reader Feedback: Not Exactly PC-Based

PLCs and PACs Are More Robust and Include More Control Capabilities Than Those Offered Through PC-Based Control

By Dan Malyszko

I worked with Noosa Yoghurt to implement the process control solution discussed in the June article, "Process Automation, Controls Boost Production at Yogurt Plant ." While most of the details on the application are accurately described within the article, this particular application does not use PC-based control. Noosa uses a Rockwell Automation PlantPAx process control system built on a server and thin-client architecture. The actual control resides within a programmable automation controller (not a PC), despite how it's referenced in the article.

In my experience, PC-based control takes the control functions found on a programmable controller, encapsulates them in software and executes program tasks and I/O communications on the PC's processor along with other overhead related to the host operating system.

PLCs and PACs, on the other hand, are more robust and include more control capabilities than those offered through PC-based control. These could include motion control, integrated safety and advanced PID process control. At Noosa, the PAC-based PlantPAx platform provides the ability to add additional I/O, controllers and servers without adversely affecting the base characterized architecture of the system. This flexibility would not be possible within a PC-based system.

Dan Malyszko
Director of Operations, Malisko Engineering Inc.
dmalyszko@malisko.com

More from this voice

Title

A Cybersecurity Wiki?

There Should Certainly Be a Wikipedia-Like Site for Security Professionals to Turn To for Proven, Tested Remedies and Suggestions

09/01/2011

An Alarming Disconnect?

The Values of Alarm Limits Are the Biggest Single Factor Governing Alarm Performance

02/14/2014

An Update on Liptak and Shinskey

Greg Shinskey Continues to Do Consulting and Bela Liptak Talks on Optimization and Safety

02/06/2012

Analog or Digital Output?

Do You Prefer Analog or Digital Output to Monitor Operating Parameters? If you Haven't Checked Out the ControlGlobal Discussion Group on LinkedIn, You Should.

09/05/2013

Answer to Our Question of the Month

Would You Pay for Outside Help to Address Cybersecurity Issues?

11/03/2011

Automation and Fukushima: Not So Fast

A Reader Responds to Liptak's Article on Fukushima Saying That We Have No Reason to Suspect That the Instruments Did Not Operate Correctly. Liptak Responds

05/01/2013

Automation Apps, Gaming Systems and Thermodynamic Steam Quality

Readers Ask for Clarification on Some of Our Latest Articles

06/07/2011

Basics of Analyzer Systems Busted!

You're Right. Here's the Correct Wording

11/03/2011

Boiler Tuning Question

What Is the Best Method to Tune PID Values for Three-Element Drum Level Control in the Boiler?

02/14/2014

Control Readers Speak Up

International Readers Lets Us Know About Automation Training Opportunities Abroad and One of Our Readers Challenges Our Contributing Editor, Bela Liptak

03/08/2011

Cyber Vulnerabilities

Defending Targeted Attacks Is a Higher Bar. Focus on Prevention Alone Is Probably a Mistake

02/14/2014

Feedback: Cybersecurity and the Beltway Bandits

What, Specifically, in the XO Evinces or Promotes a Lack of Understanding of the Different Cybersecurity Requirements for Business IT and Industrial Process Control Systems?

08/01/2013

Feedback: Keeping Up with the News Web

Is Cybersecurity Expert Joe Weiss on to Something Here? What Would You Do to Address the Cybersecurity Problems Joe Has Outlined?

07/11/2013

Feedback: Not All Digital Transmitters Are

One of Our Readers Takes Issue With the Reference to Manufacturers' "Digital Transmitters" in Rezabeck's Latest Article. See Why

12/03/2012

Feedback: Wireless Is Easy-Peasy

A Readers Writes In to Tell Us He Is Perplexed at the Perception of Wireless. Read More to Find Out Why

12/03/2012

Fieldbus Errors; Tweet This, Not That

Factual Errors Connected With Profibus and Foundation Fieldbus and What the Tweet!!?

04/04/2011

Getting the Kids Interested

Presentation is Key! See How a Retired Professional Inspires Kids to Be Interested in Science and Engineering. The More Flash, Splash and Wow, the Better

05/04/2012

Help for Fukushima?

Our Reader Alex DeVolpi Was Drawn Out of Retirement by the Fukushima Crisis. Find Out Why

07/04/2012

Help Wanted

Reader Tells Us We Were On the Mark Regarding the Current Job Market

08/03/2012

Hoist by our own petard

Reader Feedback from the February issue says that when the game leaves town, people are left twiddling their thumbs, and that the passivity of engineers is the true enemy, not the Chinese.

02/15/2005