Voices: Feedback

Reader Feedback: Lambda Tuning: Use It or Lose It?

Helpful If Readers Could Get Better Information Than What's Listed in The Last "Control Update" Under: "Cascade Control Recommendation Tips" in Greg McMillan's "Control Talk" Blog

By Sigifredo Nino

It would be very useful if the readers could be better informed than the recommendation listed in the last "Control Update" under the title: "Cascade Control Recommendation Tips" in Greg McMillan's "Control Talk" blog.  Number 8 is "Do not use setpoint filters on lower loops. Use lambda tuning for coordination of flow loops (e.g., maintaining stoichiometry for inline blending and reaction control). Set the lambda (closed-loop time constant) of each loop to match the lambda of the slowest loop.' I find it very saddening that even after someone of the stature of Greg Shinskey gets his paper, "A Case against Lambda Tuning" (http://bit.ly/1m8qygm) published in your May 2012 magazine, and that over the years, several people from industry and academy, including one of the inventors of the IMC tuning, have acknowledged the inherent deficiency of the method to cope with the most frequent dynamic behavior found in process control, your magazine keeps promoting it through this type of recommendation.

Sigifredo Nino
Summa Control Solutions

Greg McMillan replies:

Let me first say I think Greg Shinskey has provided an understanding of the effect of process and equipment design on dynamics and PID control in his books that goes far beyond what anyone else has done.

I shared Shinskey's concern about lambda tuning for over a decade. The major concern centered on a reset time that was much larger than what is needed to return to setpoint after a load disturbance to self-regulating processes with a large time constant to dead time ratio. Many of these loops are very important in that they involve concentration, pH and temperature control of large, continuous, liquid unit operations such as distillation, neutralization and reaction. A second concern was the lack of derivative action for these processes.

I realized about two years ago that if I switch from lambda tuning rules for self-regulating processes to lambda tuning rules for integrating processes with derivative action, when the time constant to dead time ratio became greater than three and I used a lambda equal to half the dead time, the problem that Shinskey raised about the recovery from load disturbances largely goes away. In fact, the tuning settings converge to those of the Ziegler-Nichols reaction curve method and many other tuning methods based on minimizing the peak and integrated error for disturbances at the process input (load disturbances).
In the lambda integrating process tuning rules, the lambda becomes the arrest time for the load response, which is more appropriate for these processes. In the lambda tuning rules for self-regulating processes, lambda was the closed-loop time constant for a setpoint response. The rate time is set equal to the secondary time constant in a second order plus dead time approximation. If the secondary time constant is not identified, I use one-half of the dead time as an inferred secondary time constant.

To provide more robustness and less tendency for the loop to oscillate, I have since used the rule of thumb to switch from lambda tuning rules for self-regulating processes to lambda tuning rules for integrating processes when the time constant to dead time ratio is greater than four, and use a lambda equal to the dead time. To deal with unknown nonlinearities that cannot be corrected by adaptive tuning and for interaction that cannot be corrected by decoupling, and to reduce resonance from disturbance oscillations with a period close to the ultimate period of the loop, I have increased lambda to be three dead times.

For more of this discussion, go to the comments section on article "Cascade Control Recommendation Tips."

More from this voice

Title

Is STEM Education Gone for Good?

Employers Today Abuse the H1-B Visa Program and Want to Pay Next to Nothing for a "Rocket Scientist"

03/05/2012

IT versus ICS

If You Really Want Folks Involved in ICS Security They Need a Safe Place to Learn

06/10/2013

Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire?

Our Very Own Ask the Experts Moderator Bela Liptak Learns a Lesson From One of Our Readers. Liptak Admits That Even Knowledgable People Can Be Wrong

02/06/2012

Misplaced ICS-CERT Priorities

If Not Asked, ICS-CERT Can't Help

04/03/2012

More About VFDs

Why Flow Control With a VSD on a Pump Is for the Most Part Linear

01/05/2012

More on Fukushima

Harry Forbes Disagrees with Bela Liptak's Automation Could Have Prevented Fukushima Article. Find Out Why

06/10/2013

More STEM Ideas

Teacher Encourages Students to STEM Careers by Providing Them With Magazines That Feature STEM Careers

06/06/2012

Nice Article

Reader's Agree With Cybersecurity Article

11/03/2011

One Page Short of a Story?

Why Would You Not Mention the Most Popular Meters That Measure Both Area and Velocity?

10/02/2012

Process Manufacturing and Society's Current Values

Society Has Devoted the Last 40 Years to Passing the Message That Manufacturing Is Dirty, Dangerous and Unrewarding

04/03/2012

Reader Feedback: Basic PID and Control Issues

Voices From the ControlGlobal Community...Our Readers Talk About PID

04/02/2013

Reader Feedback: Car Collisions and Process Control

A Good Challenge Is to Improve Car Process Dynamics, and Reduce the Final Control Time-Element Delay

10/09/2013

Reader Feedback: Consider These for The Top 50 Automation Companies

Readers Asks Us to Consider Balluff, Sick (Optical Sensing Products) for Our Top 50 Automation Companies

01/01/2013

Reader Feedback: Cybersecurity Risk

When Will the Government Take Cybersecurity Risks Seriously?

04/02/2013

Reader Feedback: From the ControlGlobal Community

More Readers Chime in to McMillan's Emergency Shutdown of LPG Tank Farms Article

12/17/2013

Reader Feedback: Lambda Tuning: Use It or Lose It?

Helpful If Readers Could Get Better Information Than What's Listed in The Last "Control Update" Under: "Cascade Control Recommendation Tips" in Greg McMillan's "Control Talk" Blog

05/02/2014

Reader Feedback: Long-Distance Calibration

A Reader Writes In to Tell Us That the Users We Quoated in an Article Are Not Considering the Latest Technology Presented at an ISA International Instrumentation Seminar

04/01/2013

Reader Feedback: No Complete Disconnect for Nuclear Plants?

You Can't Isolate a Nuclear Power Plant from Any External Data Communications

04/07/2014

Reader Feedback: Old Dogs Learning New Tricks

Why Are We Still Using the Same Sample Preparation Techniques That We Used 40 Years Ago?

01/14/2014

Reader Feedback: Pervasive Sensing

Our Vision of Pervasive Sensors Encouraged Us to Find Innovative Ways to Not Just Power Sensors

03/05/2014