Voices: Hebert

A Too-Smart Solution?

The benefits of installing smart metering systems in the plight of utilities are clear, but implementation is complex.

By Dan Hebert

Dan Hebert, PEBy Dan Hebert, PE, Senior Technical Editor

The plight of utilities trying to install smart metering systems is familiar to those in process plants, who have tried to implement large-scale data integration projects. In both cases, the benefits are clear, but implementation is fiendishly complex.

Electric utilities need smart metering systems to mitigate peak loads, and reduce the amount of required electrical generating, transmission and distribution capacity. For decades, smart metering systems for residential utility customers were envisioned, but rarely implemented.

The original idea was perhaps too ambitious. Each residential customer would have his or her own smart meter that would measure power usage and would include high-speed, two-way communication with the utility’s command-and-control system. Residential customers would be informed of the real-time price of electricity via a digital readout device mounted inside the home. The utility would adjust this price upward or downward to control usage. Informed customers would willingly and actively cut their electricity usage at times of peak demand.

There are at least three problems with this vision. First is the huge expense of installing smart meters and digital readout devices at every residence. Second is the substantial cost of linking each meter back to a central command-and-control system via a high-speed data link. Third are the significant data-management challenges, which are especially acute since there is no common standard for data exchange among meter manufacturers and meter data management software firms. The final nails in the coffin of these meter-management schemes are the need for real-time pricing and the requirement for customers to react to changes in price.

But this is a classic case of simpler being better.
I recently signed up for a relatively “dumb” residential peak load-shaving program, and I have high hopes that the program will save me money and help my electric utility, Southern California Edison (SCE), trim peak demand in a cost effective manner.

According to Scott Hirth, a manager at SCE, the A/C cycling program allows SCE to temporarily turn off residential air conditioner compressors during Southern California power emergencies. Participation is strictly voluntary, and participants receive credits of up to $200 on their summer season electric bills.

SCE’s peak demand occurs during summer weekday afternoons, typically between 2 p.m. and 6 p.m. The company estimates that peak residential air conditioning demand is approximately 3,400 MW or about 16% of total summer weekday afternoon peak. So if SCE could get half of its customers to sign up for the A/C cycling program, it could cut peak demand by about 8%. About 240,000 or 12% of SCE’s residential customers are presently enrolled.

The beauty of this program lies in its simplicity. SCE just installs a small (8 h x 8 w x 3 d in.) radio-controlled contactor outdoors on or near the A/C compressor. The contactor is powered from the same 240-V AC source as the compressor itself. The contactor interrupts the 24-V DC on-off signal from the in-home thermostat to the compressor. The installation only takes about an hour, and the technician doesn’t need to enter the house.

Communications between SCE and the contactor are also simple. Instead of the two-way data link required by “smart” systems, all that is needed is a one-way, low-speed radio signal to the contactor. This VHF radio signal is transmitted to the contactors from SCE’s grid control center via radio towers placed throughout the utility’s service area.

Perhaps most important, required customer action is also simple. They don’t have to do anything because their A/C compressor is shut off automatically. The only drawback from the customer’s perspective is that the A/C compressor fan will keep running during contactor activation as long as indoor temperature remains above the thermostat set point.

The key lessons learned from this program are these: simplicity is a virtue; wireless works when it is applied in an undemanding application; and—the one applicable to many other arenas—technical types often become so enamored of elegant and all-encompassing smart solutions that they forget about much simpler and almost-as-effective “dumb” ones.

More from this voice


A Too-Smart Solution?

The benefits of installing smart metering systems in the plight of utilities are clear, but implementation is complex.


Advanced Process Control Ain't Easy

End Users and Suppliers Agree: Advanced Process Control Is a Powerful and Effective Tool, but Implementation and Maintenance Need to Be Simplified


Advanced Process Control-Complex Solution for Complex Problems

Recent Advances Have Reduced the Cost and Complexity of Implementation and Maintenance, Making APC a Viable Option


Advances in IT Improve Process Automation

Virtualization, Thin Clients and Other Technologies Borrowed From IT Data Centers Are the Next Big Thing in Process Automation


Aero-Derivative Advanced Control

What's APC and What's Just a Collection of Clever Programming Blocks?


Alarm management improves plant operations

Alarm management is a hot topic, perhaps because incorrect presentation of alarms often confuses operators. This article shows how better alarm management empowers operators to improve plant performance.


An alarming situation

Alarm systems of one type or another always have been part of industrial machine, robot, and skid control systems, but CONTROL Senior Technical Editor Dan Hebert, PE, notes that there's more to alarm technology than meets the eye ... or ear for that matter.


Analyzers not ready for prime time

It is easy to see why the analyzer market doesn’t work for end users, but it is harder to find a solution. Clues can be found, however, in one small part of the analyzer market that is improving rapidly.


Applied control theory moves out

Industry group gets automation industry support from companies that believe the partnership between industry and academia is most beneficial when theory moves out of the classroom and into the plant.


Are Integrated Safety/Security Systems Secure?

Process Plant Safety Used to Be Relatively Simple


Automation Professionals Fill the Gap With Off-Site IT Teams

Advantages and Disadvantages of Having a Remote IT Department. What Works for Your Business? Should You Manage IT from Off-Site?


Automation Professionals Work From Home

There Are No Reasons One Could Not Work On Project Files Anywhere


Automation Software: Using SharePoint on a Project

Maverick Said Customizing SharePoint Was the Key to Project Cohesiveness and Success


Automation and Process Control Specialists: Roll Your Own

How to Be Successful When Hiring New Automation Professionals


AutomationXchange event report

While basic plant-floor automation is no longer a mystery, advanced control often is, making techniques for solving difficult process control problems of high interest to end users and service providers.


Basic Training -- Cybersecurity Style

Cybersecurity Is a Must-Have Skill in Your Process Automation Toolbox.


Before You Buy Your Next IPC, Read This

An Industrial PC (IPC) Can Perform Just as Well as a DCS or a PLC, and Thin Clients May Offer Additional Benefits


Calibrate This—Electronically

Moving From a Paper-Based System to an Automated One Can Bring a 15% to 25% Improvement in Efficiency


Calibration Can Be Condition-Based

Calibrating Industrial Devices Only as Needed Is the Better Method, and That Requires Automating the Calibration Process


Cloud-Based Asset Management

Suppliers Can Use the Cloud to Provide Remote Access to End Users, and to Analyze Data for Asset Management and Other Purposes