Voices: Lipták

SIS: Standards by Committee

SIS Committees Don't Like Plain English. Their work is Peppered with High-Tech Buzzwords, Abbreviations and Acronyms That Make These Documents Harder to Read and Hence Less Valuable

By Bela Liptak

We all know the saying that the "camel is a horse designed by committee." Today's safety instrumented system (SIS) standard (ANSI/ISA 84.00.01 (2004), which is a relaxed version of IEC 61508/61511 (1996), is not a camel yet, only a camel baby. It can still be trained, but training needs trainers! Before explaining why I say this, let us look at what a safety integrity level (SIL) is.

Read more

More from this voice

Title

Cockpit Flight Control; PCV with Closed Failure Position

Readers asks Our Experts About Safe and Economic Self-Regulating Valves, and Advancements in Cockpit Flight Control Systems

01/16/2014

"Overrule" Safety Automation; Minimum Control Valve Size

A Reader Asks Our Experts to Explain "Underwater Nuclear Reactors" and "Overrule Safety." Plus, What's the Minimum Control Valve Size in an Oil Pipeline?

02/19/2014

How Is Adjusting Cascade Control Algorithms Like Herding Cattle?

Herding Controls: Why Control Engineers Should Think Like Cowboys

03/06/2014

Can Ziegler-Nichols Equations Be Used to Tune Non-Interactive Controllers?

Our Experts Chime In and Talk about How Tuning Has Changed Since We Entered the Digital Age

04/11/2014

The Incredible Fiber-Optic Flowmeter

Online, Real-Time Multiphase Measurements Improve Safety of Oil and Gas Production

05/02/2014

Can Bidirectional Flow Be Metered for Custody Transfer?

Our Experts Debate and Discuss the Pros and Cons of Two Flowmeters

06/19/2014

How to Find Sealed Sensors, plus Pitot Tubes on Airplanes

Our Experts Discuss the Pros and Cons of Sealed Sensors and the Role Pitot Tubes Could Play in Aviation

06/25/2014

New Advances in Flow Instrumentation

Need for Transporting and Accurately Metering Oil, Gas Prompted Latest Developments Says Lessons Learned Columnist Béla Lipták

07/15/2014

What Is the Proper Role of Automation?

Automated System Can Lead to More and More Complexity and Confusion. Until the Instruments, Automation and Controls get Extremely Reliable, We'll Still Need to Keep Humans in the Loop

08/21/2014

Automatic Override control Could Have Prevented the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Well Accident

Keeping a Pipe Straight That Was What Was Needed to Prevent the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Well Accident

09/08/2014

Critical Level Measurement; Novice Engineer's Library

How to Install Three Magnetostrictive Level Gauges and What Are Some Good Instrumentation Books?

09/18/2014

Controller Action and Positioner Rules

Two of Our Readers Ask Our Experts to Clarify Their Views on Controllers and Positioner Rules

10/27/2014