Voices: Lipták

Critical Level Measurement; Novice Engineer's Library

How to Install Three Magnetostrictive Level Gauges and What Are Some Good Instrumentation Books?

By Bela Liptak

Q: Please clarify how to install three magnetostrictive level gauges (reflex/transparent type) in a vessel to measure the same level. What should the nozzle projection be? Is it possible to install three magnetostrictive level gauge transmitters in a two-of-three configuration? Are three gauges applicable or not necessary? If it's not necessary to use three magnetostrictive, level-indicating transmitters (LITs), how should one install two level gauges (reflex/transparent type) in a vessel to measure the same level? Please provide any sample sketch or isometric drawing for a level gauge that I might use for reference and review.

R. Muthuganesan
muthuganesanr@gmail.com

A: In my experience, we now use a median selector in all cases, and do not use averaging when using three measurements. The only time we're using averaging for level measurement is on large-diameter tanks, when there would be measurement differences due to waves.

Simon Lucchini
Simon.Lucchini@Fluor.com

A: The options to increase level measurement reliability are these: You can use two sensors and average the readings, but in this case, if one fails or needs recalibration, you don't know which it is. If you use three LITs and a "median selector" strategy to control on the basis of the reading of the gauge in the middle (2 in Figure 1), you will get good control, but you will not know which of the remaining two needs recalibration. Therefore, on the most critical applications, such as nuclear reactor cooling water level measurement, I use the two-out-of-three voting system in the following way: If (A + B) < 2 in., I just add up the three readings and average them. If, on the other hand, (A + B) > 3 in., I compare the distances A and B in Figure 1, select the two that are closer to each other (1 and 2), and average them for control. At the same time, an alarm is actuated which requests immediate maintenance and recalibration for sensor 3.

As to the proper installation of magnetostrictive LIT (Figure 2, p. 86), it's the same as that for large-chamber reflex gauges. You can buy them as a unit, or insert their cable version (up to 20-m long and good for high temperature and 2,000 psig) into existing gauges.

Béla Lipták
liptakbela@aol.com

Q: I am a student of instrumentation engineering. I have a diploma of associate engineer (DAE), and I'm starting more education. I want instrument books and other references that would be helpful for me.

Can you advise me on what instrumentation books to choose? I need books that relate to level, flow, temperature, pressure, pneumatics, hydraulics, electromechanical, viscosity, gravity, etc.

Muahammad Numan
mnuman016@gmail.com

A: Understanding that, as a student, you're on a limited budget, I recommend joining the International Society of Automation (ISA) as a student member. (They have subsidies, I believe.) Also, I'd investigate signing on to the LinkedIn bulletin boards relating to our field, which are accessible through the ISA and others. Perhaps, at this point, some of the topics discussed are a little obscure or advanced, but getting exposed to the vernacular of the trade and, more importantly, to actual field applications helps with the learning experience.

Peter Baker
Pbaker@ivyautomation.com

A: The best start on instrumentation reading is Omega's instrumentation handbooks. They're available as printed books, and most are also available under "Technical Reference" on Omega's web pages. [Editor's note: They're also available as PDFs.]

Based on my 47 years in the instrumentation field, the best books came from vendors. They supplied you with a lot of technical data to help you do your job and to prevent you from getting bad data. This brought repeat customers to their products.

I don't know their current availability, but I still hold dear my personal copies of these books. They provide practical applications, details and data about all things instrumentation-related. They may not go into the highly technical details available in more weighty books, but these books will educate you in how do apply instrumentation without boring you:

Transducer Interface Handbook, A Guide to Analog Signal Conditioning by Daniel H. Sheingold was available from Analog Devices Corp. [Editor's Note: It may not be available from the company any longer, but typing the title and author into Google will bring sources where it's still available.]

Data Acquisition and Control Handbook from Keithley.

Pressure Transducer Handbook by CEC Instruments Inc., is a really good book. It pushes the ISA test methods and reports. [Editor's Note: CEC is now part of Omegadyne. This book may no longer be available.]

Handbook of Measurement and Control, by Schaevitz Engineering. [Available used online at bit.ly/1roOFKo.]

Signal Conditioning & PC-Based Data Acquisition Handbook by IOTech. [Available as a PDF at bit.ly/1v2EXOm.]

Bruce Land
Bruce.Land@jhuapl.edu

A: A very good overview of the automation profession in a single book that includes the items you're looking for can be found in A Guide to the Automation Body of Knowledge, 2nd Edition, by Vernon L. Trevathan (bit.ly/1p7pMPT). It provides a general overview of automation and references where you can get more information.

Curt Wendt
WendtCW@cdmsmith.com

A: Some years ago, when I was in your situation, I used to download and store every article, to say nothing of books, of which I felt a need. I'm sending you some of these that fall into the categories you have mentioned, but remember that the Internet today is a live library, and every day more books are put on its shelves. So my advice to you is to always search this library (the Internet) for updated information. For example, I Googled "instrumentation and control engineering pdf" and got on the first page:

The Control & Instrumentation Principles Reference Manual (bit.ly/1oNYsGW);
Process Measurement and Analysis by Béla Lipták (amzn.to/1vJrcW2 );
Control & Instrumentation Principles (bit.ly/1oNZ6V2);
Measurement and Control Basics by Control Station (bit.ly/1kCetzs).

Avihu Hiram
Avihu@HiramEng.com

A: As for textbooks, consider Handbook of Instrumentation by Andrew Stiller

For applied instrumentation, I recommend Applied Instrumentation in the Process Industries: Volume 3, Engineering Data and Resource Manual, Third Edition, by William G. Andrew and H.B. Williams. I would also recommend American Petroleum Institute (API) "Recommended Practices (RP) 551."

Joseph Amalraj
rjosephamalraj@gmail.com

A: You can find free technical e-books in places at links like www.freeengineeringbooks.com and www.engineering108.com.

Alejandro Varga
vargaalex@yahoo.com

A: Since you are a student and a beginner, I would not recommend my nearly 2,000-page handbook. Instead, you should start with reading freely accessible introductory publications:

"Engineers Level Measurement Guide" (2013) from Rosemount (bit.ly/1kCf3xc)
"Measurement and Control of Liquid Level" from ISA (amzn.to/1lVGr4O)

Or go to Wikipedia and look up the sensor of interest. For example, if you want level sensors, you will get a brief summary at bit.ly/1ra2tbA and at the end, plenty of references for further reading.

Béla Lipták

More from this voice

Title

Ultrasonic Flowmeters for Paper Pulp; Flowmeter Accuracy

A Reader Asks if Controlotron System 1010P Universal Portable Flowmeter Can Measure Pulp Flow With 1.5% Consistency. Also, Why Vendors' Literature, Often Give Accuracy Measurements as a Percentage but Without Stating of What

06/14/2013

Relief Valve Blowdown Rings; D/P and Straight Runs

Readers Ask: When It Comes to Safety Relief Valves, What Is Best? Using Two Blowdown Rings or Ones? and Can a Transmitter Be Installed Above Pipe Taps?

05/07/2013

Automation Could Have Prevented Fukushima, 2

Bela Liptak Discusses Automatic vs. Manual Operation of the Emergency Cooling Systems, and the Roles the Bad Designs of Control and Block Valves Played in this Nuclear Accident

04/30/2013

Sealing an Oil Well; Orifice Sizing--OSO versus AGA

Can Someone Explain BP's Sealing Process to Temporary Seal the Oil Well from the BP Oil Spill in the Mexican Gulf? And, What Is the Difference Between the Orifice Calculations Described by AGA 3 and ISO 5167?

04/10/2013

Automation Could Have Saved Fukushima

Liptak Says That If the Fukushima Level Detectors Had Operated Correctly, the Hydrogen Explosions Would Have Been Prevented

03/15/2013

Loop Drawings for Smart Instruments

Readers Look to Our Experts for Information on Smart Instruments

03/12/2013

Automation Could Have Prevented Chernobyl

Bela Liptak Tells How Automatic Safety Controls Could Have Prevented the Accident at Chernobyl

01/10/2013

Cascade, Scan Time, PID Tuning

When Should You "Slow Down" a PID Loop by Making the Loop Update Time Such That the Loop Executes Less Often?

01/09/2013

Emergency Shutdown of LPG Tank Farms

Is It Allowed from the Standard Point of View to Use the Existing Level Transmitters to Control the Inlet and Outlet Shutdown Valves?

12/10/2012

Real-Time PIG Data Transmission?

How Can We Improve the Safety of the Pipelining Industry? See What Our Experts Say

11/12/2012

Why Nuclear Needs Process Automation

The Key to the Safety of Nuclear Power Plants Is to Maintain the Availability of Coolants, Even if All Electric Power Supplies Fail

11/01/2012

Crude Oil Pipeline Control

Is It Possible to Maintain an Accurate and Stable Pressure Control Just Using Speed Control?

09/27/2012

Economic Controls; Cooling Tower Optimization

Readers' Ask Our Expert, Bela Lipatk, What His Opinion Is on Keen's Approach to Debuning Economics and to Give Some Advice on the Conceptual Design of Cooling Tower Optimization

09/10/2012

Improving Oil and Gas Well Safety

Liptak Walks Us Through Step-by-Step How Process Control Can Improve the Safety of Fracking, Off-Shore Drilling, Well Blow-Out Prevention, Drilling Ship Stability and Much More

08/29/2012

"Herding" Control and LPG Problems

A Reader Asks Us if "Herding Control" Is a Theoretical Concept, or a System that Our Very Own Bela Liptak Designed. Also, What Is the Suitability of Using a Differential Pressure Cell Pressure Transmitter.

08/10/2012

D/P Cell Accuracy; Which Manifolds Are Best?

A Reader Aks our Panel of Experts How He Can Tell If His D/P Transmitter is Accurately Calibrated. See What Our Experts Had to Say

07/16/2012

Drilling Safely in the Arctic Ocean

Liptak Shows Why Full Automation Could Improve the Safety of Offshore Drilling in and Transportation from the Arctic Ocean

07/03/2012

Valve Failure Positions; Controlling Global Processes

Readers Ask About PID Controller Action, Valve Failure Positions and Global Process Trends for Industrial Applications

06/12/2012

Tuning Interacting Controllers

Is the Famous Ziegler-Nichols (ZN) Open-Loop Tuning/Closed-Loop Tuning Parameter Calculation for Interacting or Non-Interacting PID?

05/14/2012

Controls for Drilling Oil and Gas Wells

The Drilling for Oil and Gas Will Be With Us for Some Time, the Only Contribution Our Profession Can Make Is to Improve the Safety of These Processes

05/04/2012