Voices: Lipták

How to Find Sealed Sensors, plus Pitot Tubes on Airplanes

Our Experts Discuss the Pros and Cons of Sealed Sensors and the Role Pitot Tubes Could Play in Aviation

By Bela Liptak

Q: In your book, Instrument Engineers' Handbook, your examples all seem to be related to fluids and not dust-laden gas (as in flue gases). I'm interested in sealed sensors. Who manufactures them? We have challenges from dust particles affecting total air measurement on our forced draft (FD) fans. The dust comes from recirculating lines that feed back to the FD fan suction, which we use for dew point control during boiler start-up.

Richard Mahupete

A: Unfortunately, I can't help you. I've been looking for an instrument for almost the same application for 20 years, but in vain. In my case, we have a big gas duct 11 feet in diameter carrying gas that has about 0.5% of fine coke dust at 1,100 °F. This gas, a mixture of CO, SO2, amine, waste fuel gas (CH4, H2, etc.) and flue gas, comes from a coker at very high velocity, and is fed to a CO boiler used as incinerator. We have three ducts that are lined with 4 in. of slag.

I was told that ultrasonic flowmeters do not work at high temperatures, hindered by the four inches of slag and by big swings in the gas flow that occur frequently due to process upsets upstream. In the past, these have caused trips and explosions in the precipitators of the CO boiler downstream, and also black gas diversions for over 24 hours. I will be watching the replies to this question closely.

Gerald Liu, P. Eng.

A: You could measure fan power (not current!) to get a reasonable measure of flow. Modern motor protection relays (e.g., Multilin) can be set up to measure power.

Simon Lucchini

A: Many of the standard manufacturers — Rosemount, Endress+Hauser, ABB, Honeywell — build transmitters that have sealed sensors. But to be able to give a better answer you need to supply more detailed information, such as use of the instrument, process variables, type of dust contaminants and concentrations, etc., since some applications may have easy solutions, while others may be more complex. See these links here and here

Alejandro Varga

A: You might try using a thermal mass flow sensor that inserts into your stack connected to a transmitter.

M. Conella

A: You did not give the duct/pipe size, operating temperature, presence of slug build-up, etc. Therefore, the options below are uncertain. If your temperature is less than 500 °C, consider a thermal probe, and obtain a bid for a retractable unit (bit.ly/1nqAfHA). If there is no slug buildup, but the temperature is high, consider a Doppler cross-correlation ultrasonic sensor (bit.ly/1kFHmIy).
If your duct/pipe is large (meters), segmental wedge is an option. If slug build-up is heavy, purge the pressure taps. If not, use chemical seals with ceramic diaphragms and syltherm filling in the capillaries.  If all you need is repeatability, you can try a retractable Pitot with strong purging, such as this one.

Béla Lipták

Q: In a past column, you wrote about air transportation safety and the role of automation that should and could be increased to improve it. You also mentioned something about the role of Pitot tubes and their features. Could you elaborate?

H. Crowney

A: You are right. In an age when we can send robots to Mars and drones to chase terrorists, it is strange that we cannot automatically prevent pilots from attempting to land at the wrong speed, or automatically stop ferry captains from turning into high-speed currents at sharp angles, or automatically prevent drivers from switching lanes when a high-speed car is coming in that lane. In short, it is hard to believe how strong our “manual culture” is, and how many Fukushimas it will take before we accept the fact that 45 minutes between the earthquake and the arrival of the tsunami is enough to flood the reactors with cooling water only if it is done automatically, but that this will not occur if we expect it to be done by panicked operators waiting for the approval of CEOs.

While Pitot tubes are used in other industries, where they are considered to be one of the less accurate and reliable flow sensors, in the field of aviation, they play a critical role in measuring both the speed and the altitude of airplanes. Thousands of these Pitot detectors are still in use on operating airplanes.

Figure 1 shows the locations of the Pitot tubes (Part A) that inform the captain and the first officer of the speed and altitude of the plane. A third sensor is provided as a backup in case all the others fail. Part B shows the physical appearance of a Pitot unit, and Part C the cross section of an early design, where the differential gauge reads only the difference between the static and the Pitot pressure, and was scaled to read velocity. Part D shows the design today. Here, the air speed indicator is the same as before, but in addition to velocity, the static pressure is also read in units of altitude (altimeter), and the vertical speed of the plane is also detected by indicating the rate of change in the altitude (static pressure).

The Pitot tube itself is provided with a drain hole and with a heater for deicing. Interestingly, the deicing heater is not started automatically by outside temperature, but is turned on manually by the pilot. In addition, there is no way for the pilots to know if the Pitot tube is plugged, although a simple fiber-optic sensor could detect that, and purge cleaning could automatically be started as soon as a plug is detected.
These are some of the reasons why I believe that the aviation industry could take better advantage of safety automation.


More from this voice


Automation Could Have Saved Fukushima

Liptak Says That If the Fukushima Level Detectors Had Operated Correctly, the Hydrogen Explosions Would Have Been Prevented


Loop Drawings for Smart Instruments

Readers Look to Our Experts for Information on Smart Instruments


Automation Could Have Prevented Chernobyl

Bela Liptak Tells How Automatic Safety Controls Could Have Prevented the Accident at Chernobyl


Cascade, Scan Time, PID Tuning

When Should You "Slow Down" a PID Loop by Making the Loop Update Time Such That the Loop Executes Less Often?


Emergency Shutdown of LPG Tank Farms

Is It Allowed from the Standard Point of View to Use the Existing Level Transmitters to Control the Inlet and Outlet Shutdown Valves?


Real-Time PIG Data Transmission?

How Can We Improve the Safety of the Pipelining Industry? See What Our Experts Say


Why Nuclear Needs Process Automation

The Key to the Safety of Nuclear Power Plants Is to Maintain the Availability of Coolants, Even if All Electric Power Supplies Fail


Crude Oil Pipeline Control

Is It Possible to Maintain an Accurate and Stable Pressure Control Just Using Speed Control?


Economic Controls; Cooling Tower Optimization

Readers' Ask Our Expert, Bela Lipatk, What His Opinion Is on Keen's Approach to Debuning Economics and to Give Some Advice on the Conceptual Design of Cooling Tower Optimization


Improving Oil and Gas Well Safety

Liptak Walks Us Through Step-by-Step How Process Control Can Improve the Safety of Fracking, Off-Shore Drilling, Well Blow-Out Prevention, Drilling Ship Stability and Much More


"Herding" Control and LPG Problems

A Reader Asks Us if "Herding Control" Is a Theoretical Concept, or a System that Our Very Own Bela Liptak Designed. Also, What Is the Suitability of Using a Differential Pressure Cell Pressure Transmitter.


D/P Cell Accuracy; Which Manifolds Are Best?

A Reader Aks our Panel of Experts How He Can Tell If His D/P Transmitter is Accurately Calibrated. See What Our Experts Had to Say


Drilling Safely in the Arctic Ocean

Liptak Shows Why Full Automation Could Improve the Safety of Offshore Drilling in and Transportation from the Arctic Ocean


Valve Failure Positions; Controlling Global Processes

Readers Ask About PID Controller Action, Valve Failure Positions and Global Process Trends for Industrial Applications


Tuning Interacting Controllers

Is the Famous Ziegler-Nichols (ZN) Open-Loop Tuning/Closed-Loop Tuning Parameter Calculation for Interacting or Non-Interacting PID?


Controls for Drilling Oil and Gas Wells

The Drilling for Oil and Gas Will Be With Us for Some Time, the Only Contribution Our Profession Can Make Is to Improve the Safety of These Processes


Magmeter Maintenance, Feed-Forward Variations; Robots

What Maintenance Is Required for a Magmeter? And What's the Difference Between "Positional Feed-Forward" and "Incremental Feed-Forward" in PID Control?


Using Feed-Forward PID for External Reset

Is There a Way to Create an External Reset on a Standard PID Feedback Controller?


Scraping the Bottom of the Barrel-Part 3

Liptak Discusses Pipelining Safety and How Automation Processes Can Prevent Pipelining Accidents


Deaerator Level Control

Can a P Controller Be Replaced With a Linear Function Generator in Controlling the Level on a Deaerator?