Voices: Montague

The Long View and Valley Power

Technology Is Only as Good as the People That Use It and Interpret Its Data, so It Takes a Commitment to Training, Setup and Implementation

Jim MontagueBy Jim Montague, Executive Editor

Time speeds up as we get older, but 10 years is still a big chunk of chronology. And in this stressed-out era of 24/7 news, showbiz fads, financial scandals and other distractions, it can be difficult to focus on unglamorous commitments—good marriages, raising families, consistent professionalism— or staying warm next to Lake Michigan.

Sure, global warming may one day turn Milwaukee into a tropical hotspot, but, for now, most of its downtown area by the lake needs the steam heat it gets from We Energies' Valley Power Plant. This venerable plant is the largest utility-owned, co-generation facility in the United States. It haa two 280-megawatt units, and its four coal-fired boilers produce 1.25 million pounds per hour (MLb/hr) of steam.

In the most recent decade of its continuing mission to provide and improve its service, Valley Power has steadily transitioned from using stand-alone laptop PCs and multiplexers and moved to using Emerson Process Management's online AMS Device Manager and its Ovation interface. This journey was described by Todd Gordon, We's instrument technician leader at Valley Power, at the recent Emerson Global Users Exchange in San Antonio, Texas.

"Now, we all have to love technology, but we know it can create an overload unless training and implementation are coordinated," says Gordon. "We've also learned that technology such as AMS can't solve every problem. If your hardware and mechanics aren't set up properly, then your overall system isn't going to work. Technology is only as good as the people that maintain, use it and interpret the data, so it also takes a time commitment for training, proper setup and implementation."

Built in the 1960s, Valley Power initially used local, pneumatic controllers for pressure, temperature and level and an I/P converter, which was upgraded from E/P in 1993. Gordon reports the plant's journey to AMS really began when it installed its first "smart," non-HART transmitter in 1988. Then, in 1993-94, DCS controls were installed at Valley Power. Likewise, in 1993, the plant gained its first "smart," non-HART positioner, which used DOS-based software that required a Windows 98 laptop.

"The main question is can the newer, smart instrument do its job better than the older technology? We've usually found that the answer is yes," says Gordon. "Fisher DVC positioners also provided an input to DCS for valve position from the HART signal. These were on our two most critical valves. So when the positioners told us the valves were getting sticky, we decided to replace them, and this saved us from tripping out units three times."

Later, Valley Power added Base Station with Multiplexers in 2004. These enabled online, continuous monitoring when hardwired to HART devices. "The base station communication from the handhelds and laptops are very useful, but we still like to go and see the valves move," added Gordon. "There are still some things you can only see when you're there."

Even newer devices at Valley Power include its HART diagnostic transmitters, and it plans to add wireless devices soon. Most recently, the plant replaced its multiplexers with Emerson's Ovation interface and spent part of this year working on a new DCS controls upgrade, in which the base station will be integrated into the DCS controls.

"In general, our performance monitoring has given us better tuning of controls, improved heat rates for reduced fuel consumption, faster ramp rates for changing load demands, centralized performance monitoring and predictive maintenance," added Gordon. "All of this has been a journey, not a destination. We found that online capabilities increase effectiveness of smart instrumentation and supporting software. However, you can't maximize a plant's efficiency if you can't accurately control and effectively manage the final drive elements."

Pretty cool, that is, if you can wake up from present-day distractions, become aware of some important history and take that longer view.

More from this voice


Maybe You Didn’t Hear Me

Why do engineers and their companies tolerate safety standards that aren’t enforced until after accidents occur, and why do they accept safety device certifications that only cover compliance in lab-based settings?


Survey Snapshots Wireless Users

CONTROL recently conducted its first SP100 Wireless Survey of almost 500 readers about where and how they use wireless in their plant-floor applications.


A Willingness to Learn

You Can Teach an Old Dog New Tricks—and Old Editors and Engineers Too.


A Willingness to Learn

You Can Teach an Old Dog New Tricks—and Old Editors and Engineers Too


Get Out the Process Control Vote

Society Could Use Some of that Technical Know-How that Process Control Engineers too often Leave Back at Work


The Best Gift

For Kids, Connecting with the Larger World, Including Its Technology and Engineering, Means First Connecting with the People Closest to Them


Bean Control Engineers Needed

There Are Too Many Parasites Waiting to Steal Working People’s Money, and Executive Editor Jim Montague Thinks Engineers Could Protect Them from Financial Worst Practices


Finding Data Diamonds

Detecting Problems Early Mean Having the Time and Ability to Make Informed Decisions


Shell's Long-Time Push for Fieldbus

What's Next? Making Foundation Fieldbus Systems More Mature. Meaning, Making Them More Broadly Applicable in Projects


Security Standards Stewpot Simmering

Process Controls Engineers, IT Technicians, Manufacturers and End Users Have Been Left Hungry as Government Departments, Trade Organizations and Corporations Struggle to Develop and Coordinate Basic Standards for Securing Industrial Networks and Software


Two Days in Austin

I’ve Never Attended a Tradeshow Where at Least a Dozen Parents Brought Their Kindergarteners to Try Out the Equipment


Everything Old is New Again

A Specific Tool May Be obsolete, but the Mental Process That Went into Addressing the Problem It Solves Remains as Instructive as Ever


Worry Wart

A Flood Around Your Ankles Is a Lot Different Than One Around Your Neck. So Pick Up Your Canoe and Get Moving


Paralyzed by Profits

Unrestrained Prosperity Is a Disease, so It’s Tragic That Drug Manufacturers Don’t Want to Take Their Medicine. Just Like The Rest of Us


Skills Shift to Software

Engineers Must Now Keep Up with a Lot of Microsoft Hot Fixes and Software Patches to Solve Vulnerabilities


Good Talk

Invite Folks from Other Departments or Organizations In for an Informal Lunch-and-Learn Tour or Some Speed-Dating-Style Tabletop Displays


Chips Are Up

The Chasm Between the Plant Floor and the Data Processing Center Remains Huge, Wide and Deep


Don't Forget Object Lessons

Can You Become a Prisoner of Your Lego-like Software Modules?


Process Simulation Pans Out for Goldmine

Barrick Gold Is Using Mynah's MiMiC Software to Simulate Multiple Processes for Training Operators and Improving Performance at Its New, $3.7-Billion Gold Mine in the Dominican Republic


Securing Your Sustainability

Here Are Some Basic Ways to Go Green That Can Be Used Across Different Processes