Voices: Rezabek

Why HART and Foundation Fieldbus Don't Just Get Married

The Disparate Origins of These Protocols Mean a One-Size-Fits-All Heir Is Unlikely

By John Rezabek

How do you tell a HART device from a Foundation fieldbus (FF) device? There have been times when we've puzzled over it. Did the supplier make a mistake and send us a HART device when we ordered FF? On the surface, devices of the same heritage and generation have little beyond a subtle difference in the model number to distinguish themselves. With the merging of the HART Communication Foundation and the Fieldbus Foundation, some have wondered if there will be some new offspring, or if devices from one protocol will become conversant in the other. Foundation fieldbus and HART technologies have a lot of things in common. Why wouldn't they play nicely together some day?

Read more

More from this voice

Title

Instrinsic Safety Obsolete Yet?

Like Most End Users, I Truly Value the Credibility and Security That Organizations Such as Factory Mutual, the Canadian Standards Association, CENELEC and Their Ilk Bring to the Devices We Use in Hazardous Environments. But Perhaps One Practice is Ready to Be Relegated to the ISA Museum of How We Used to Do Things. Here’s Why.

03/07/2008

Paving the Way for Bus Technology

I’ve Had Great Success on Projects, Especially Upgrades and Retrofits, Where I Was Able to Get an Experienced Board Person and/or Front-Line Supervisor Assigned to the Job

02/04/2008

Right Message, Right Person, Right Time

Data Doesn’t Always Equal Information. Why Can’t We Get Alarm Information to Our Operators in a More Meaningful Way?

01/03/2008

Yikes! Look out for that Chasm!

The best practice by far is to choose a main instrument vendor who is accountable for the integration of all field devices.

12/03/2007

Load ’Em Up!

If we know the element will respond in a second at best, why compute a new output four times a second?

11/06/2007

Portable Diagnostic Tools – Who’s the Best?

So what do I grab when heading out the door to troubleshoot a suspect segment? More often than not, it’s the FBT-6.

09/27/2007

Lipstick on Modbus

There are people who would rather take a flogging than maintain an OPC installation.

08/31/2007

Justifying Fieldbus, Part I

Asset management and wiring saving cost were common justifications for installing Foundation fieldbus in refineries 10 years ago. Today, the cost to replace DCS with electronic field devices must be justified.

07/13/2007

One bus for all?

When it comes to applications that allow our basic controls to function, system lock-ups are intolerable, so it pays to examine the heritage of fieldbus and carefully analyze the market that shaped it.

05/06/2007

Tolerate less redundancy

Today, with Foundation fieldbus, the old redundancy paradigm no longer applies. Chances are, though, it isn’t free. So where should you apply it to achieve the fault tolerance you need?

12/05/2006