Voices: Tales From the Front

Distillation control and optimization, Part 1

CONTROL columnist Bela Liptak describes the distillation process and PID-based controls, reviews optimization strategies, and shows how advanced controls can cut operating costs of distillation.

Distillation Columns at an Oil RefineryBy Béla Lipták, PE, CONTROL Columnist

Distillation is a common, energy-intensive separation  method, but its control technology hasn’t changed much since the 19th century. The thermal energy needs of distillation are enormous, while the thermodynamic efficiency of its processes is less than 10%, so serious savings can be gained by better controlling and optimizing it. Here and in the January and March 2007 issues, I’ll describe the distillation process and PID-based controls, review optimization strategies, and show that advanced controls can cut operating costs of distillation by more than one third.

Composition Control
Conceptually, product quality is determined by the heat balance of the distillation column. Heat removal determines the internal reflux flow rate, while heat addition determines the internal vapor rate. These determine the circulation rate, which determines separation between two components. The first task in configuring a column’s control system is to configure the primary composition control loops.

Composition Control Using Analyzers
Analyzer controllers in a feedback configuration can only be considered when the dead time caused by analysis update is less than the response time of the process. The composition controller provides a feedback correction in response to feed composition changes, pressure variations or changes in tower efficiencies. In Part A of Figure 1 below, the analyzer controller (ARC) uses the chromatographic measurement to manipulate the reflux flow by adjusting the set point to the reflux flow controller (RFC).

Feedback Configuration
Part A: Composition control by cascading reflux flow as slave controller (FRC). Part B: Smith predictor with dead time compensation. Part C: Control by triple cascade of ARC to TRC to FRC. Part D: Absorber bottoms composition control (ARC).

Smith Predictor
Controllability of the process is degraded by the dead time between measurement updates. In Part B of Figure 1, the Smith-predictor compensator provides a process model in terms of its time constant and dead time, and predicts what the analyzer measurement should be between analysis updates. The multiplier (AY), first order lag (AY) and dead time (AY) provide the required inputs to the calculation of the predicted analysis. This predicted response is subtracted from the actual measurement (AY+/-) to give a differential of the actual process from its own model. This delta is added to the model (AY∑) without dead time to provide a modified pseudo-measurement to the analyzer controller.

Triple Cascade
The purpose of all cascade systems is to provide slave(s) that will correct for disturbances before they can upset the primary or master controller. Part C in Figure 1 illustrates a triple cascade loop, where a temperature controller is the slave of an analyzer controller, while the reflux flow is cascaded to temperature. Cascade loops will work only if the slave is faster than the master, which adjusts its set point. Therefore, in Part C, the time constants of the flow controller (FRC) must be much smaller than those of the TRC.

Selective Control
Part D illustrates a limit control configuration where the analyzer controller is overruled when the temperature reaches its high limit. The temperature controller is a constraint preventing the temperature from exceeding a limit at the bottom of an absorber stripper. Selective control configurations also require external feedback to protect them from reset windup. Part D shows a combination of selective and cascade systems.The master of the FRC is selected to be either the TRC or the ARC. The external reset (ER) signal is taken from the measurement of the slave controller (FRC).

[Editor's Note: Look for the complete ebook, Distillation Control and Optimization on ControlGlobal.com in January, 2007.]

  About the Author
Bela LiptakBéla Lipták is editor of the Instrument Engineer’s Handbook, and former chief instrument engineer at C&R (later John Brown). He is a recipient of ISA’s Life Achievement Award (2005) and member of the CONTROL Process Automation Hall of Fame (2001).

More from this voice


Distillation control and optimization, Part 1

CONTROL columnist Bela Liptak describes the distillation process and PID-based controls, reviews optimization strategies, and shows how advanced controls can cut operating costs of distillation.


Ghost writers on the web

New detection software programs that generate relevant text on a given subject are getting better at identifying existing content, but a casual reading shows most of what they reveal has no meaning.


Morley sees manufacturing’s future

Dick Morley, creator of the modern PLC, provides wit and accumulated wisdom to how a simple understanding of technology and marketing can supply the core for a successful new product.


Living control systems?

Self-reconfiguring and assembling devices may have some surprising unintended consequences. We’re talking the potential for almost unlimited versatility that could change the international balance of trade.


The relay logic syndrome

The coming together of nanotechnology, biology and medicine, information sciences, and cognitive sciences should give traditional automation and control devices new performance and capabilities.


Illusions of freedom and security

As our society moves towards a more regulated work environment, choosing between the cubicle life or being self-employed has become more difficult. CONTROL contributor, Dick Morley, provides informal tips.


Seven commandments for successful integration

Other Voices contributor Scott Little provides a clear example on the importance of good communication and why a concisely written description of operation is a good idea.


Occupational therapy for the control engineer

Can companies and technologies adapt to change in a positive manner? CONTROL Contributor Dick Morley says yes and believes that with some occupational therapy, you can survive!


The past, present and future of PLCs

Famous futurist and 2005 ISA Rimbach Lecturer, Jeff Harrow, contributes to the discussion of the future of process automation and how today’s PLCs will eventually feel like the TTL logic chips of older days.


More tech, more tech, more better tech!

This "special to the web" edition of Tales From the Front offers concrete suggestions on how the industry can help create true economic profit, while at the same time increase its knowledge base.