Get the Most Out of Your Batch

The Same Techniques Used to Get the Most Ethanol Out of a Scarce Corn Crop Can Help You Optimize Other Batch Processes

By Greg McMillan

Share Print Related RSS
Page 1 of 2 « Prev 1 | 2 View on one page

Most of the effort to date in optimization has been in continuous plants using the well-established tool of model-predictive control. Except for my article, "Unlocking the Secret Profiles of Batch Reactors" (Control, July 2008), most of the published effort on batch optimization has been in the use of data analytics and, more specifically, projection to latent structures (PLS) to predict endpoints as discussed in the Control Talk columns "Drowning in Data, Starving for Information" (Feb-May, 2010, see sidebar below).

There are some innovative, easy-to-implement general solutions to increase batch efficiency and capacity that take advantage of the qualification of batches and the prediction of end points by data analytics or analyzers. The test case is the front end of an ethanol plant with batch fermenters, but much of the methodology is applicable to batch reactors for food, beverages, drugs and chemicals.

Initial Opportunities

When I was leaving for college, my dad said, "Make sure you use a good grain analyzer to optimize alcohol batch time and yield." Good advice, dad. These words of wisdom would be useful in the years to come at "Purple Passion" parties with tubs of grain alcohol and grape juice. The greatest value was seen 40 years later for ethanol plant optimization opportunities.

The control strategy takes advantage of an off-line or at-line analyzer of corn yield (fermentability) to provide with corn feed rate an inferential measurement of production rate as the process variable for a simple flow controller. An enhanced PID is used to deal with variable update time of the feed analyzer. The operator sets the production rate for the front end of an ethanol plant that includes a parallel train of batch fermenters. When the corn analyzer indicates the corn fermentability has increased, the ethanol production rate controller cuts back corn feeder speed, immediately translating the increase in yield to a decrease in corn feed rate. Since corn is more than 50% of the ethanol cost, the reduction in cost of goods (COGS) is significant—especially this season with a drought-compromised corn crop.

A change in fermentability also corrects the setpoint for slurry percent solids control. The tricky part here is the setting of lags to mimic the residence times of the slurry tanks and the delay to match the turnover time.

Feed-forward control is added to make production rate changes smoother. If the operator changes the production rate of the front end to better match up the back end distillation and purification capability, the dilution water flow setpoint automatically changes to maintain the current ratio of water-to-corn feed rate.

When an off-line analyzer indicates a fermenter has reached an endpoint, the average fermentation time for the 10 fermenters is updated. A fraction of the equivalent change in fermentability from the average is taken as a bias correction to the analyzer signal.

More Opportunities

More recently, I realized I could use the slope of the batch profile for ethanol (ETOH) concentration to decide whether to end or extend the batch based on the value of additional yield and capacity. When the ETOH concentration approaches the endpoint, the slope starts to flatten out, since the alcohol concentration inhibits the yeast. If you convert the slope to ETOH gallons per minute and multiply by the analysis time interval, you have the additional ETOH until the next analyzer update. If you divide the current ETOH gallons in the batch by the number of corn bushels effectively used in the batch, you have a simple estimate of the yield in terms of ETOH gallons per bushel. If you divide the additional ETOH per batch by the yield and multiply by the cost per bushel, you have the dollar value of the additional ETOH by extending the batch. If you take the current ETOH gallons in the batch and divide by the current batch time in minutes, you have the current fermentation production rate (ETOH gpm). You could also get the production rate from the flow controller based on corn fermentability. If you multiply the production rate by the profit ($/gallon) and the analysis time interval, you have the value of additional capacity by terminating the batch. A polynomial fit of the profile based on previous historical data can offer more accurate estimates, particularly if the time between analyzer updates is large.

Page 1 of 2 « Prev 1 | 2 View on one page
Share Print Reprints Permissions

What are your comments?

You cannot post comments until you have logged in. Login Here.


No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments