Choose and Manage Your Automation Suppliers Carefully

How Can We Manage Our Supplier Performance to Achieve Optimum Long-Term Results

By Roy Kok

The technologies we choose have a major impact on our careers and the competitiveness of our companies. With the total cost of ownership being over four times the initial acquisition and installation cost, the choices are much more important than they may at first appear. Making the right choice can end your career or launch it. However, for the company, the choice that is made, even a bad one, will be in place until the end of its useful life.

With leaner engineering departments and changing technologies to choose from, selecting the right solution is an ever-growing challenge. So the question becomes, "What's the best process for making a strategic selection." The follow-up is "How can we manage our supplier performance to achieve optimum long-term results."

First you need to understand that selecting the right technology will require both research and a team effort. You need to clearly define the scope of the project. Have you had a past solution, and why are you considering a change? What are the key benefits you're seeking? Do you want to improve quality? Agility? Performance? Reduce costs? What are the attributes that will make your company more competitive? After all, isn't that the ultimate question?
Selecting the right supplier will require the development of an extensive criteria list. A highly technical solution will typically have over 150 criteria to evaluate. These will fall into one of three categories:

  1. Capabilities – In this category, you are evaluating the current capabilities of the company and its products or services. Are they features you need, and can this company provide them? Does the company have technical support in your region? Is there a local training department? Are parts stored locally.
  2. Presence – In this category, you are evaluating the current stability, growth and penetration of the supplier and its products or services in your context (region and/or industry). Is the company a relevant supplier of this technology or service? Is it successful in my industry? In my region? Is it growing?
  3. Vision – In this category, you are evaluating the alignment of the company with your corporate goals and future vision. Is the candidate company developing technology that you will be using in the future? Is it investing in this technology? Is it supporting future standards? Is it staffing as you want it to to provide the kind of support you will need?

Your evaluation criteria should be straightforward, easily understandable and, ideally, drive a quantitative response. Make sure your question facilitates a scalable result. For example, a question about support personnel could be, "Do you have support personnel in my region?" However, a better question would be "List the support personnel you have in my region and give their history." Creating criteria that prompt yes/no responses do little to help compare one solution to another.

Think as broadly as possible about your selection criteria. Don't forget to include categories for integration with other business systems, long-term ownership and career planning (How will ownership transition to new stakeholders as careers advance? How will new users be brought up to speed?). Don't forget to consider items you will encounter over the life of a system; e.g., upcoming technologies, standards or enhancements to your business practices.

Once you've made your selection and implemented the system, you'll need to move on to supplier performance relationship management (SPRM), and focus on maximizing the benefits of this selection over the lifecycle of the solution.

It is a fact that for strategic and complex technology solutions, the total cost of ownership over the lifecycle of the product is over four times the initial cost of acquisition and implementation. You have service costs, technology upgrades, spare or replacement parts, training, consulting and continued engineering. These are all important categories to consider in making the initial selection, but they are also important areas to manage on an ongoing basis to maximize the benefits of the system and the value derived through your relationship with the supplier.

Here too, a formal process to manage the relationship is critical. When you mention supplier relationship management (SRM), those in the purchasing realm will see it as managing your supply chain. There are many SRM products on the market for that purpose.

In the world of automation, where a strategic selections revolves around a technology such as a distributed control, manufacturing execution or enterprise asset management system, the need is not in managing ongoing deliverables and product quality, but in continually evaluating, managing and improving your service relationship (Figure 1).

Just as with supplier selection, quantifiable criteria are important. You can't improve what you can't measure. and you can't measure something you can't put a number to.

This is an area that ARC Advisory Group sees as underperforming across the industry. This area is better known as supplier performance and relationship management (SPRM). Even the companies that have formal SPRM processes can quickly identify areas that require improvement. These usually involve training and consistency across the organization.

The key to effective supplier performance and relationship management involves three areas:

  1. KPIs – The right items to measure, year over year, to gauge that your relationship and the services provided are healthy and on track.
  2. Process – A regimented and controlled process delivering repeatability, year over year, even with changing personnel or corporate stakeholders.
  3. Scorecard – A simple tool that summarizes the relationship performance and helps to guide constructive discussions that will lead to mutually beneficial results.

Read Also: Of Swiss Cheese, KPIs and Process Safety

The KPIs, when properly defined, enable you to manage one vendor with a single or multi-site deployment and compare multiple vendor performances against each other. The key is to create a framework and process that will enable continuous measurement and continuous improvement. The result will be improved performance, managed costs and maximized adherence to your business objectives (quality, throughput, uptime, etc.).

Many companies implement such programs for supplier selection or supplier management, but in ARC's experience, rarely are they implemented with a degree of consistency or thoroughness that should be expected for such strategic components in the operation of a company. This is an area where improvement can lead to a significant return on investment. 

Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.


  • Tracking USPS shipping USPS Tracking: Track the status of United States Postal Service parcel. Enter USPS tracking number and then click the button on the Track USPS.


  • Track the status of United States Postal Service parcel.


  • aadhar card status enquiry aadhar card update status aadhar card status by name aadhar card correction aadhar card application aadhar card status enquiry phone number aadhar card address change


  • if you want to track your parcel then you can visit you will get the best and complete information regarding your parcel.


  • USPS, which is abbreviated as United States Postal Service is an independent and a self-supporting federal agency in the United States is the best and most popular delivery service that reaches every address in the country among 155 million houses, industries, and several Post Office Boxes. USPS is an incredible Postal Service that takes usps tracking no tax dollars for functioning expenditures and depends on the sale of stamp price, products, and facilities to invest its procedures.


  • It is a very interesting post!! keep up the good work by sharing more such stuff


  • i really appreciate the content of this i get the best informative stuff.thanks for i provide the best news of usa which you can check here.


  • here is complete detail for usps services


  • here is complete detail of best hospitals in usa


  • TS SSC RESULTS 2017 : TS Board has also known as Telangana Board of Secondary Education conducted the SSC Board exam in the month of March 2017. Students, who appeared in the examination hall at the time of annual exams, are waiting for the now. This year also, large amounts of students appeared in the examination to perform well and to score the maximum marks. Students will able to check their ts ssc results 2017. AP SSC RESULTS : Andhra Pradesh Education Board Bseap Will going to Release 10th Class SSC Results on 3rd May 2017. Candidates who had appeared for the AP SSC results 2017. Exams are waiting to fetch their results. BSEAP is going to declare AP 10th Class results 2017. For more visit: 10th results 2017 Source:


  • Word preparing fax cover sheet templates are simple resignation letter conventionally included as a Attendance Sheet 2017 normal element in most word Letter Of Employment handling programming. resignation letter samples What's more, clients of such programming frequently have the choice to make and spare their own templates


  • Thank you for the information you provide, it helped me a lot! it's great that I known this site! Can you sharing some updates on how you have made this powerful post! It will be easier to track your mail and know exactly what should be in your usps mail holdusps hold mail each day.The usps postal service is introducing a new program called Tracking Delivery.The program is similar to tracking a package which is going to deliver.Once package delivered it will be information will be updated. Automatically track all packages coming to you. Set up email and text alerts, so you never have to manually track a package again. Provide delivery instructions, so your carrier knows where to leave packages through usps tracking


  • thanks for sharing such a amazing stuff.i really appreciate this here is best collection of happy 4th of july messages and happy 4th of july quotes and happy 4th of july images


  • I see your blogs its so amazing and helpfull for us .you share a great idea.Please upload more post in different topics likeupcoming sports events in world  ,Hollywood Movies etc.


  • Tattoo is an ink design added into the skin, generally with the help of a needle. This procedure has prehistoric roots, it has been used by people for thousands of years, in various forms. Examples can be seen in the majority of human cultures, and despite some societal stigma, tattoos are getting to be ubiquitous in the West, with an estimated 25 percent of American people are wearing at least one by the end of the twentieth century. tattoo ideastattoo ideas for men


  • it become very interesting when i think about to visit this website.every time when i visit here i get the best informative stuff.some time it really helped me to solve many problem and that's the reason i usually visit this when in searching for useful content and of course many time i get best informative stuff here .here we will discuss about the best good night stuff which i very useful in relationship.for good night here is best collectionhappy birthday messages for girlfriend good morning quotes for husband happy birthday quotes for sister good morning quotes for wife


  • USPS, which is abbreviated as United States Postal Service is an independent and a self-supporting federal agency in the United States is the best and most popular delivery service that reaches every address in the country among 155 million houses us mail hold usps tracking number post office change of address


  • Apple released iOS 11 beta download for developers around the globe. It is available for download on iPhone and iPad devices.


  • Really a great addition. I have read this marvelous post. Thanks for sharing information about it. I really like that. Thanks so lot for your convene. geometry dash five nights at freddy’s


RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments