Pushing against Jello…

Even experts don't understand"¦or we haven't done a very good job of making the issues known and understandable I had the opportunity for formal and informal meetings yesterday with some very influential and knowledgeable people in Washington. One of the two individuals I want to focus on is Jim Lewis from the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).  Jim provided the membership list for the Blue Ribbon Panel on Cyber Security. I had the opportunity to explain the control system cyber security issues and why traditional IT approaches may not be appropriate for non-Windows-based field devices. I also had the opportunity to state that the industrial control systems community needs to be "at the table" when issues involving control systems are discussed - IT should not be speaking for us. As a result of this discussion, we may get a seat on the Blue Ribbon Panel. On the flight home, I sat next to Francis Harvey. Francis is the ex- Secretary of the Army and managed among other organizations the Westinghouse Science and Technology Center. He is very knowledgeable about IT and security. He is obviously in the senior decision making ranks. However, control system cyber security issues were new to him and why IT is not directly relevant to field devices took him by surprise. He was also stunned that control system networks are not isolated and there is Internet-connectivity to control system networks. Until people at these levels and influence understand the message, we are pushing against jello. Joe Weiss
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.


  • <p>Hi Joe Seasons greetings.</p> <p>I have seen the list of panel members and I am surprised to see you say that Control systems were not represented.</p> <p>I am of the understanding that what you have said here now means 3 people are representing the community or certainly have the right people behind them to leverage the right language and understanding.</p> <p>For certain we need to empower our decision makers with the necessary knowledge as to the uniqueness of control systems but we also need to partner more effectively with the other technology or branches of science otherwise this starts to sound more like empire building and less about what I know is your goal?</p> <p>We can all bemoan the us n them routine but at some point we have to shake the stigma off and do something positive and affirmative about this all.</p> <p>I think the committee has a great balance of people with the knowledge and skills to put together a very comprehensive plan for your next president elect to work with. Lets work on bridging this knowledge gap and assisting the committee to put together the best plan for everyone's needs.</p>


RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments