Readers’ Feedback February 2008

Feb. 4, 2008
Our Readers Have a Lot to Say About Our Articles. This Month, We Get Responses on Control En Español, Selling Engineering to Kids And More

Spanish Version a Hit

Ví tu reciente comentario “Expandiendo Nuestra Covertura.” Muchas felicitaciones por su sección en español.  Así técnicos e ingenieros de habla hispana pueden beneficiarce de la excelente información que ofrece. Mucho exito en tu empresa. Espero ver y participar con comentarios en los meses venideros.

Recently, I watched your Automation Minute “Expandiendo Nuestra Covertura.” Congratulations for your Spanish section. Spanish-speaking engineers and technicians can benefit from excellent information that offers on online spaces such as this one. I wish much more success for ControlGobal, and I hope to see more information and participate with comments in upcoming months.

Marco A. Rodriguez PE, CAP
Automation Engineer
Bomac Incorporated
East Syracuse, N.Y.

More on Control Valve Simulation

The discussions on control valve simulation in the December issue were interesting, but I think they miss a major point: all these models assume a constant source and sink process pressure. In real life, this isn’t so.

For example, one reason for selecting an equal percentage valve is to maintain, at worst, a linear flow versus stem position relationship, not a kitchen-faucet function, since in most installations, the wider the valve opens, the more the delta P across the valve body drops as the rest of the hydraulic (or gaseous) system components like piping, heat exchangers,  etc. absorb more of the available system pressure drop. This is not a negligible effect and should be included in any realistic simulation, particularly when looking at dynamic stability.

Robert M. Green
Gloucester, Mass.

Selling Engineering to the Kids

For years, as a member of the Roanoke Branch of the American Society of Civil Engineers, I visited local schools to exhort high school kids to consider a career in engineering; it was almost always difficult to find other engineers to go with me. Further, I proctored local MATHcounts competitions, and I was for years an ASCE-sponsored visitor to ABET, the accreditation service.

I never had a boss who didn’t hold his nose over these activities. I worked as a consultant in the private sector exclusively, and there engineers are rated on productivity, the percentage of paid hours that are billable—and time away to visit some college or to talk to high school kids in the name of some vague, nebulous future can put a serious dent in group productivity stats (and this year’s bonuses).

I imagine it’s even worse now that design shops are seeing work tag-teamed around the globe, 24-hours a day.

What we need, desperately, is an all-out Sputnik era-style push for engineers and scientists—and it’s not likely to happen.

Bob Felton, PE
Editor, Civil Commotion Blog
Wake Forest, N.C.

What’s In a Name?

I couldn’t agree more with your article, “What’s in a Name?” in the December 2007 issue. I am an instrumentation and controls engineer and an active member of our local ISA section. One of the biggest challenges I face is explaining to other people what I do. Explaining it in a concise manner is difficult. Discussing ISA with colleagues and college students and encouraging them to join is even more difficult. It’s imperative that we clearly communicate what our profession is about, and “automation” is the best word to do that.

Todd McKinney
Westlake Chemical Corporation
Calvert City, KY.

Sponsored Recommendations

Measurement instrumentation for improving hydrogen storage and transport

Hydrogen provides a decarbonization opportunity. Learn more about maximizing the potential of hydrogen.

Get Hands-On Training in Emerson's Interactive Plant Environment

Enhance the training experience and increase retention by training hands-on in Emerson's Interactive Plant Environment. Build skills here so you have them where and when it matters...

Learn About: Micro Motion™ 4700 Config I/O Coriolis Transmitter

An Advanced Transmitter that Expands Connectivity

Learn about: Micro Motion G-Series Coriolis Flow and Density Meters

The Micro Motion G-Series is designed to help you access the benefits of Coriolis technology even when available space is limited.