The Caro Report: Dick on EDDL, FDT/DTM

April 23, 2007
From an email earlier this month, Dick Caro writes: I have written several articles on FDT/DTM. Originally, I was quite negative about this technology, but after being "educated" by several field instrument suppliers I have finally resolved the important differences between FDT/DTM and EDDL. I thought that this information would be good to share with my fellow SP104 committee members.The most basic difference between them is that -- * FDT/DTM allows the ins...
From an email earlier this month, Dick Caro writes: I have written several articles on FDT/DTM. Originally, I was quite negative about this technology, but after being "educated" by several field instrument suppliers I have finally resolved the important differences between FDT/DTM and EDDL. I thought that this information would be good to share with my fellow SP104 committee members.The most basic difference between them is that -- * FDT/DTM allows the instrument supplier to format the HMI screen display for that instrument * EDDL allows the HMI supplier (typically the DCS vendor) to format the screen display for all field instrumentsI have polled several end users with this generality, and they mostly agree that it is more important that they not train their process operators for each type of field instrument. They want the DCS supplier to control the look-and-feel of the HMI.However, in my conversations with some instrument suppliers, I find that there are some diagnostic and calibration displays that cannot be made available via EDDs (they tell me). They find that they can COMPLEMENT the EDD with their own tools by using FDT/DTM. I have no reason to doubt their conclusion. While DCS and independent HMI suppliers can offer a wide variety of graphic tools, I am sure that creative instrument suppliers knowing the deep technology of their sensing and actuation methods can create high added value displays that only they know about, particularly for diagnostics.There are many other technical and procedural differences that may be important in competitive situations, but my overall conclusion is that these are COMPLEMENTARY technologies.

Sponsored Recommendations

Municipalities are utilizing inline total solids measurements to enhance sludge thickening, lower polymer usage and cut operational expenses.
Carbon dioxide is increasingly recognized as a vital resource with significant economic potential. While the conversion of carbon dioxide into products is still in its infancy...
Discover our wide range of temperature transmitters that convert sensor signals from RTDs and thermocouples into stable and standardized output signals!
An innovative amine absorption-based carbon capture process enables retrofitting of existing industrial facilities to reduce emissions in hard-to-abate sectors, with advanced ...