Hardware blowback

Usefulness measures the middle way between physical and digital solutions

Key Highlights

  • Zine creators worry that easy digital research can weaken the effort and practice behind creative thinking.
  • Resistance to data centers and renewed interest in vinyl reflect broader tensions between digital convenience and physical experience.
  • Nostalgia can obscure the frustrations of older technologies, just as enthusiasm for new ones can hide their costs.

It’s probably professional jealously, but as you may know, I’ve been fuming about the likely shortcomings of artificial intelligence (AI), especially the amount of human labor required to prepare data for it to analyze, and the human expertise needed to fix its many errors. As I said before, if so much people power is needed on both ends, what’s the value of this AI middleman, and can it be eliminated? Of course, my argument is already being proven wrong on several fronts.

Checking further afield, however, I recently found multiple individuals who view AI with even more suspicion than me. I was recently, selfishly investigating whether print publishing has any future, and ran across Chicago’s vibrant zine and micro-publishing communities at the city’s Harold Washington Public Library and elsewhere.

Several young authors, illustrators and self-publishers report distrusting AI, automation and even the Internet as efficient but imagination-killing because they make research too easy. They believe excessive digitalization stifles the mental striving and practice needed to develop creative solutions. In fact, they appeared to think most forms of digitalization are like the Tamagotchi electronically simulated pet toys many of them grew up with. They’re amusing and diverting at first, but soon demand so much button-pushing “feeding” and attention that they quickly turn their users into stressed-out busywork slaves. Sound familiar?

Remember Tamagotchis? The electronically simulated pets were amusing at first, but soon demanded so much button-pushing ‘feeding’ and attention that they turned users into stressed-out busywork slaves. Sound familiar?

As much as their publications could use the exposure, this is why several young zine producers add they don’t even indulge in setting up websites. A little harsh, but I found myself mostly agreeing with them.

These sentiments appear to parallel several similar, Luddite-style trends, most notably the emotional and even virulent protests against planned data centers in many U.S. locations by the same populace that relies on them. AI, cloud-computing, software and their networks always need physical servers running somewhere, so TikTok videos and the ability to comment on them are always at our fingertips—just not in my backyard (NIMBY). No surprise that crowd is alive and squawking.

Get your subscription to Control's tri-weekly newsletter.

Likewise, a newly opened Barnes & Noble bookstore in Oak Park, Ill., appears to be betting its future survival on a large, vinyl LP record section, and even sells turntables. Yikes. Good luck to them—and who can be sure?—but I wouldn’t put my $2 on that horse, mainly because I remember scratched and warped record albums. I also recall using bits of Scotch tape to splice together the two ends of tapes that had broken in cassettes, which is why I and pretty much everyone welcomed the increasing freedom of CDs and downloadable audio. I even experimented and failed to somehow infuse ink back into old typewriter ribbons, which thankfully hasn’t been a problem since writing went onscreen.

Just as I’m suspicious of the downsides of AI and digitalization, these older memories are why I’m skeptical of the fashionable rush back towards hardware. I know nostalgia obscures past times and situations that were never as terrific as efforts to revive them want us to believe.

I admit I’m an equal-opportunity grouch. However, I also know the pendulum that describes politics, technologies and most other human endeavors always swings back. Unfortunately, just like in Edgar Allen Poe’s story and Vincent Price’s movie, the blade at the end cuts in both directions. The extreme of unaccountable software, digitalization and AI, and the extreme of inflexible hardware is they’re both unhelpful and potentially destructive in the wrong amounts and inappropriate situations.

Consequently, whether it’s hardware, software, digitalization or now AI, they must all burn in the same crucible of usefulness that every other tool, service or solution should go through to determine if they’re really helpful or not. So, use switches, boxes and other physical devices if they can prove they’re still the most appropriate and efficient. Employ software and AI when they can gather, organize, analyze and deliver data that wouldn’t be reachable otherwise. Just avoid either when they’re revealed as time-sucking, energy-wasting Tamagotchis.

About the Author

Jim Montague

Jim Montague

Executive Editor

Jim Montague is executive editor of Control. 

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates